The Convergence of Regional Governance Discourses in Rural Australia: Enduring challenges and constructive suggestions
Tiffany Morrison
Lecturer, Flinders Institute of Public Policy and Management, Flinders University, SA
Marcus Lane
Lecturer, Environmental Management, Political
Geography, University of Adelaide, SA
PP: 341 - 357
Abstract
Regional governance is being embraced across rural Australia by a diverse ensemble of actors, including rural communities, private corporations, environmental activists and government agencies.
The promoters of regional governance argue that utilising approaches to governance such as ‘regional partnerships' improves the functionality and democracy of governance and enables ‘sustainable regional development'. Closer scrutiny reveals that the regional governance ideal appeals to this diverse range of interests in contradictory ways.
Concerns for environmental, social and economic sustainability intersect with concerns about economic decline, community empowerment, fragmented government, and broad-scale resource use conflicts in rural areas.
Against a backdrop of international trends in ecosystem management, new regionalism, collaborative planning and new public management, this article reviews the reasons why these diverse actors have converged on similar conceptual terrain in their search for rural sustainability. This serves to illuminate the contradictions inherent in this conceptual convergence, the challenges to achieving the regional governance ideal, and enables us to posit some constructive suggestions as to how these challenges can be overcome.
Keywords
rural policy, regionalism, regionalisation, governance, Australia
References
Alexandra, J. 1997, ‘Regions: The bastard children of cooperative federalism', Meeting the regional challenge, Greening Australia, Canberra.
Allmendinger, P. 2001, Planning in postmodern times, Routledge, London.
Amin, A & N Thrift (eds). 1994, Globalization, institutions and regional development in Europe, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Aslin, HJ, NA Mazur & Curtis AL. 2002, Identifying regional skill and training needs for integrated natural resource management planning, Bureau of Rural Sciences, Canberra.
Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics (ABARE). 1999, ‘Outlook 99: Agriculture' National Agriculture and Resources Outlook Conference, Canberra, 17-18 March.
Beck, U. 1992, Risk society: Towards a new modernity, Sage, London.
Beer, A & A Maude. 2002 Local and regional economic development agencies in Australia, Local Government Association of South Australia, Adelaide.
Beer, A, A Maude & B Pritchard. 2003, Developing Australia's regions: Theory and practice, University of New South Wales Press, Sydney.
Brown, AJ. 2004, in ‘Regionalism: An introduction' Restructuring Australia: Regionalism, republicanism and reform of the nation-state, AJ Brown & W Hudson (eds), Federation Press, Sydney.
Brunckhorst, DJ. 2002, ‘Institutions to sustain ecological and social systems' Ecological Management and Restoration, vol 3(2), pp 108-16.
Burdge, RJ. 1998, A conceptual approach to social impact assessment: A collection of writings by Rabel J. Burdge and colleagues, Social Ecology Press, Middleton.
Cheers, B & AE Luloff. 2001, ‘Rural community development', Rurality bites: The social and environmental transformation of rural Australia, S Lockie & L Bourke (eds), Pluto Press, Sydney.
Cheshire, L & G Lawrence. 2005, ‘Reshaping the state: Global/local networks of association and the governing of agricultural production', Agricultural governance: Globalization and the new politics of regulation, V Higgins & G Lawrence (eds), Routledge, Abingdon.
Commonwealth of Australia. 1949, Regional planning in Australia: A history of progress and review of regional planning activities through the Commonwealth, Department of Post-war Reconstruction, Canberra.
Considine, M. 1994, Public policy: A critical approach, Macmillan, Melbourne.
Dale, A & J Bellamy (eds). 1998, Regional resource use planning in rangelands: An Australian review, Land and Water Resources Research and Development Corporation, Canberra.
Daly, M. 2000, ‘The challenges for local government in the 21st century', in Land of discontent: The dynamics of change in rural and regional Australia, B Pritchard & P McManus (eds), University of New South Wales Press, Sydney.
Dollery, B & L Crase. 2004, ‘A critical note on ‘eco-civic regionalisation' as the basis for local government boundaries in Australia', Australian Geographer, vol 35(3), pp 289-300.
Dore, J & J Woodhill. 1999, Sustainable regional development, Greening Australia, Canberra.
Dore, J, J Woodhill, K Andrews & C Keating. 2003, ‘Sustainable regional development: Lessons from Australian efforts', in Managing Australia's environment, S Dovers & S Wild River (eds), Federation Press, Sydney.
Edwards, M & J Langford (eds). 2002, New players, partners and processes: A public sector without boundaries? National Institute for Governance, University of Canberra, Canberra & Centre for Public Studies, School of Public Administration, University of Victoria, VIC.
Ehrenberg, J. 1999, Civil society: A critical history of an idea, New York University Press, New York.
Eversole, R & J Martin (eds). 2005, Participation and governance in regional development: Global trends in an Australian context, Ashgate, Aldershot.
Ewing, S. 1999, ‘Landcare and community-led watershed management in Victoria, Australia', Journal of the American Water Resources Association, vol 35(3), pp 663-73.
Farrelly, M. 2005, ‘Regionalisation of environmental management: A case study of the Natural Heritage Trust, South Australia', Geographical Research, vol 43(4), pp 393-405.
Fitchen, JM. 1991, Endangered spaces, enduring places: Change, identity, and survival in rural America, Westview Press, Boulder, CD.
Forester, J. 1989, Planning in the face of power, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA.
Gerritsen, R. 2000, ‘The management of government and its consequences for service delivery in rural Australia', Land of discontent: The dynamics of change in rural and regional Australia, B Pritchard & P McManus (eds), University of New South Wales Press, Sydney.
Gray, I & G Lawrence. 2001, A future for regional Australia: Escaping global misfortune, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Hall, P. 1992, Urban and regional planning, Routledge, London.
Hamel, P, H Lustiger-Thaler & L Maheu. 1999, ‘Is there a role for social movements?' Sociology for the twenty-first century:, in Continuities and cutting edges, JL Abu-Lughod (ed), University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Healey, P. 1997, Collaborative planning: Shaping places in fragmented societies, MacMillan Press, London.
Herring, M. 1999, ‘Introduction', in Bioregional assessments: Science at the crossroads of management and policy, KN Johnson, F Swanson, M Herring & S Greene (eds), Island Press, Washington, DC.
Higgins, B. 1989, ‘Australian regional development in international perspective', in Australian regional developments: Readings in regional experiences, policies and prospects, B Higgins & K Zagorski (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
Higgins, V & G Lawrence (eds). 2005, Agricultural governance: Globalization and the new politics of regulation, Routledge, Abingdon.
Hoggett, P. 1996, ‘New modes of control in the public service', Public Administration, vol 74 (Spring), pp 9-32.
Hogwood, BW & BG Peters. 2000, ‘Diffused or diverse?: Explaining patterns of public employment', American Political Science Association Annual Meeting, Washington DC.
Holmes, J. 2002, ‘Diversity and change in Australia's rangelands: A post-productivist transition with a difference?' Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, vol 27(3), pp 362-384.
Hood, C. 1991, ‘A public management for all seasons?', Public Administration, vol 69 (Spring), pp 3-19.
Hooper, BP. 1995, ‘Towards more effective integrated watershed management in Australia: Results of a national survey and implications for urban catchment management', Water Resources Update, vol 100, pp 28-35.
Howitt, R. 2000, ‘Nests, webs and constructs: Contested concepts of scale in political geography', in A Companion to Political Geography, J Agnew, K Mitchell & GO Tuathail (eds), Blackwell, Oxford.
Jennings, SF & SA Moore. 2000, ‘The rhetoric behind regionalization in Australian natural resource management: Myth, reality and moving forward', Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, vol 2, pp 177-191.
Johnson, KN. 1997, ‘Science-based assessments of the forests of the Pacific northwest', in Creating a forestry for the 21st century: The science of ecosystem management, KA Kohm & JF Franklin (eds), Island Press, Washington DC.
Lane, MB. 2003, ‘Decentralization or privatization of environmental governance?: Case analysis of bioregional assessment in Australia', Journal of Rural Studies, vol 19(3), pp 283-294.
Lane, MB & A Corbett. 2005, ‘The tyranny of localism: Indigenous participation in community-based environmental management', Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, vol 7(2), pp 141-159.
Lane, MB & GT McDonald. 2002, ‘Towards a general model of forest management through time: evidence from Australia, USA and Canada', Land Use Policy, vol 19, pp 193-206.
Lane, MB & GT McDonald. 2005, ‘The limits to community-based environmental planning: operational dilemmas, planning principles and possible remedies', Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, vol 48(5), pp 709-31.
Lane, MB & TH Morrison. 2006, ‘Public interest or private agenda?: A meditation on the role of NGOs in environmental policy in Australia', Journal of Rural Studies, vol 22(2), pp 232-42.
Lane, MB, B Cheers & TH Morrison. 2005, ‘Regionalised natural resource management in South Australia: prospects and challenges of the new regime', South Australian Geographical Journal, vol 105, pp 11-26.
Lane, MB, GT McDonald & TH Morrison. 2004, ‘Decentralisation and environmental management: A comment on the prescriptions of the Wentworth Group', Australian Geographical Studies, vol 42(1), pp 103-115.
Lockie, S. 2001, ‘Community environmental management? Landcare in Australia', in Rurality bites: The social and environmental transformation of rural Australia, S Lockie & L Bourke (eds), Pluto Press, Sydney.
Majone, G. 1999, ‘The regulatory state and its legitimacy problems', West European Politics, vol 22(1), pp 1-24.
Marsden, T & Sonnino, R. 2005, ‘Rural development and agri-food governance in Europe: Tracing the development of alternatives', in Agricultural governance: Globalization and the new politics of regulation, V Higgins & G Lawrence (eds), Routledge, Abingdon.
Minogue, M. 2002, ‘Governance-based analysis of regulation', Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, vol 73(4), pp 649-66.
Minson, J. 1998, ‘Ethics in the service of the state', in Governing Australia: Studies in contemporary rationalities of government, M Dean & B Hindess (eds), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Morrison, TH & MB Lane. 2005, ‘What ‘whole of government' means for environmental policy and management: An analysis of the connecting government initiative', Australasian Journal of Environmental Management, vol 12(1), pp 47-54.
Morrison, TH, GT McDonald & MB Lane. 2004, ‘Integrating natural resource management for better environmental outcomes', Australian Geographer, vol 35(3), pp 243-258
O'Connor, K & M Gordon. 1989, ‘Operation of regional labour markets in Australia', in Australian regional developments: Readings in regional experiences, policies and prospects, B Higgins & K Zagorski (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
Osborne, D & T Gaebler. 1992, Reinventing government: How the entrepreneurial spirit is transforming the public sector, Addison-Wesley, Reading.
Paton, S, M Woods, A Curtis & G McDonald. 2005, Regional NRM: A social and environmental experiment, Land and Water Australia, Canberra.
Powell, WW. 1991, ‘Expanding the scope of institutional analysis', in The New institutionalism in organizational analysis, WW Powell & PJ DiMaggio (eds), University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Productivity Commission. 1999, Impact of competition policy reforms on rural and regional Australia: Inquiry report No 8, AusInfo, Canberra.
Pritchard, L & SE Sanderson. 2002, ‘The dynamics of political discourse in seeking sustainability', in Panarchy: Understanding transformations in human and natural systems, LH Gunderson & CS Holling (eds), Island Press, Washington DC.
Putnam, RD. 1993, Making democracy work: Civic traditions in modern Italy, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Rainnie, A. 2005, ‘Regional development policy and social inclusion', in Community and local governance in Australia, P Smyth, T Reddel & A Jones (eds), University of NSW Press, Sydney.
Rhodes, RAW. 1997, Understanding governance: Policy networks, governance, reflexivity and accountability, Open University Press, Buckingham.
Roberston, A & R Watts (eds). 1999, Preserving rural Australia: Issues and solutions, Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Melbourne.
Scott, JC. 1998, Seeing like a state: How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed, Yale University Press, New Haven, CT.
Scott, WR & JW Meyer. 1991, ‘The organization of societal sectors: Propositions and early evidence', in The new institutionallism in organizational analysis, WW Powell & PJ DiMaggio (eds), University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Smyth, P, T Reddel & A Jones. 2005, ‘Associational governance in Queensland', in Community and local governance in Australia, P Smyth, T Reddel & A Jones (eds), University of New South Wales Press, Sydney.
Spiller, M. 1999, ‘From victim to vanguard: The remaking of regional planning in Australia', Royal Australian Planning Institute 27th National Congress, Darwin.
Swyngedouw, E. 1996, ‘Reconstructing citizenship, the re-scaling of the state and the new authoritarianism: Closing the Belgian mines', Urban Studies, vol 33(8), pp 1499-521.
Taylor, M & S Garlick. 1989, ‘Commonwealth government involvement in regional development in the 1980s: A local approach', in Australian regional developments: Readings in regional experiences, policies and prospects, B Higgins & K Zagorski (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
Tendler, J. 1997, Good government in the tropics, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
Troughton, MJ. 1995, ‘Agriculture and rural resources', in Resource and environmental management in Canada: Addressing conflict and uncertainty, B Mitchell (ed), Oxford University Press, Toronto.
Vipond, J. 1989, ‘Australian experiments with regional policies', in Australian regional developments: Readings in regional experiences, policies and prospects, B Higgins & K Zagorski (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
Wentworth Group, The. 2002, Blueprint for a living continent, World Wildlife Fund Australia, Sydney.
Young, IM. 1990, Justice and the politics of difference, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Zagorski, K. 1989, ‘Introduction: Australian regional problems, policy and research', in Australian regional developments: Readings in regional experiences, policies and prospects, B Higgins & K Zagorski (eds), Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
eContent Home
